Peru to Sue Yale University over Hiram Bingham’s Machu Picchu Artifacts

Report: Peru to Sue Yale for Inca Artifacts

The Associated Press

November 9, 2008

LIMA, Peru: Peru has reportedly approved a plan to sue Yale University for thousands of Inca artifacts excavated decades ago by a U.S. scholar at Machu Picchu.
State newspaper El Peruano said Sunday the Justice Ministry will assign a prosecutor to press the government’s case against the New Haven, Conn. university.

It did not say when or where such a suit would be filed. Government officials could not immediately be reached to confirm the information.

Thomas Conroy, a Yale spokesman, said the university was aware of the news report.

“It is, of course, disappointing, since we had a positive informal meeting with the foreign minister, and have expected to have further discussions,” he said.

Yale has stated in the past that it will defend any lawsuit, Conroy said.

“We believe that a lawsuit does not best serve the interests of the public, both in Peru and internationally, or of posterity,” he said.

The university, Conroy added, continues to believe that “cooperation and collaboration would provide a better framework for satisfying the multiple interests in the archaeological material excavated by (Hiram) Bingham (III) at Machu Picchu.”

Peru demanded the collection back in 2006, saying it had never relinquished ownership when Bingham, a Yale scholar, rediscovered Machu Picchu in 1911 and sent thousands of ceramics, textiles and bones to the university. Peru officials have threatened to sue in the past, but never did.

Peru and Yale reached an agreement in 2008, but it fell through over a dispute over how many artifacts were to be returned. The Machu Picchu ruins are Peru’s main tourist attraction.